Starship Just Unlocked the Masterplan
Musk didn’t engage in the pedantic discourse. He just built with his teams and made the impossible happen. He...
Anxious and uncertain. That’s the mood right now… just like it was in 2022.
Managing Editor’s Note: Today, we’re spotlighting a recent issue from Brownstone’s senior blockchain analyst, Ben Lilly, over at his Chain of Thought free e-letter…
He weighs in on the state of the digital assets industry as the dust settles on the bulk of the midterms… and how this environment is reminiscent of another time when anxiety and uncertainty plagued the crypto industry.
And how folks who held off or sold then would look back just a year later and wish they hadn’t given in to that uncertainty.
You can read on for more on it from Ben. And if you want more updates and deep dives into everything that’s going on with digital assets and blockchain technology, you can go here to sign up to join Ben over at Chain of Thought.
It’s November, and there is nothing but gloom and doom on the horizon.
The price of Bitcoin dropped 22% in a week.
Midterm elections just wrapped up, and investors are unsure what to expect from D.C. in the new year.
The U.S. Federal Reserve is expected to raise rates when it meets in December.
And a calamity at one of the largest cryptocurrency exchanges is an overhang on asset prices.
This might sound like today, but it was the state of affairs in November 2022.
FTX, the cryptocurrency exchange, was filing for bankruptcy. The midterm election had just concluded, with 96 pro-crypto candidates getting ready to start the next session of Congress in two months.
And Jerome Powell was about to raise rates at the December 2022 FOMC meeting.
Let’s not forget the timing of Bitcoin either…
The Bitcoin halving was scheduled for about 18 months out. It’s an event that cuts the number of newly minted bitcoin in half. It’s coded into Bitcoin, and price tends to ebb and flow around it.
November that year also marked the beginning of a 23-month rally in Bitcoin. It was the first month of a multiyear bull run.
Nobody was excited about digital assets in November 2022. A year later, investors looked back at that period and wished they had bought more.
I believe November 2026 will be remembered the same way.
Here’s what I mean…
Binance is fresh off an attack in which more than $6 billion was stolen by a North Korean hacking group called TraderTraitor.
About half of the funds were reportedly frozen, but the rest is on the move and likely making its way into the traditional financial system.
Here’s what we wrote to subscribers of Neural Net Profits and Permissionless Investor on October 30, just after the attack:
While this hack is not an indictment of the underlying technology or asset class, it is a black eye for the industry in general. I won’t sugarcoat it: The size and scale of the heist will likely act as an overhang on prices for even the highest-quality assets. We should be prepared for that.
The overhang is due to attackers moving funds away from where they are most easily traced and recovered – public blockchains. They are cashing out.
And once the funds move into fiat, they’ll most likely be unrecoverable.
In 2022, a different disaster was unfolding at FTX.
The FTX event was not a hack. Instead, the company was trying in vain to plug a hole in its balance sheet as prices began to fall.
This meant lots of dollars were flowing out of stablecoins and into the traditional financial system. Tether, the issuer of the USDT stablecoin, processed about $700 million in redemptions in 24 hours and nearly $3 billion in a few days.
Stablecoins in circulation in 2022 dropped from $150 billion the month before to $140 billion the month after, a fall of about 6.7%.
This time, stablecoins in circulation have dropped 5.3%, from $300 billion a month ago to $284 billion today.
The FTX and Binance events are strikingly similar in forced selling and the drop in stablecoins in circulation.
And then there’s the federal government…
This information is time-sensitive. Former Wall Street insider Jason Bodner just uncovered shocking details about a rare stock market event… He calls it the “Stock Market Power Shift.” Because every time it hits, today’s top stocks lose their grip… and a new group of stocks can shoot up as high as 852%… 1,532%… and even 1,921% or MORE. The next “Power Shift” is set to begin as soon as January 3. If you have any kind of money in the stock market, you MUST hear this important information. Click here for more details.
This company once ruled American tech. Its stock fell, and Wall Street wrote it off. But Larry Benedict believes Elon Musk is about to turn it into one of the greatest U.S. comeback stories. Get the overlooked ticker now
We know the outcome of this midterm election, though a few seats remain uncalled. And for crypto, the new Congress is likely to be far more skeptical.
Anxious and uncertain – that’s the mood right now… just like it was in 2022.
Back then, the rhetoric around the digital asset industry was bleak. The market was bearish for nearly all of 2022. A wave of bankruptcies hit centralized firms such as Celsius, Voyager, BlockFi, and Three Arrows Capital.
Gary Gensler was the industry’s Darth Vader, hell-bent on beating it into submission.
Being an anti-crypto politician was a popular strategy. It’s why that incoming class had only about 96 pro-crypto candidates getting ready to start the new session in January 2023, according to the advocacy group Stand With Crypto.
The difference this time is that crypto is no longer a fringe topic that scares the average person. It’s becoming more mainstream, with 30% of adults investing in the asset class.
That suggests many constituents of these politicians are involved in crypto, unlike four years ago. That means being anti-crypto is unpopular now.
And while the overall sentiment feels negative, with Elizabeth Warren taking a leadership role on the Senate Banking Committee, we shouldn’t be pessimistic.
The truth that’s starting to surface in Washington, D.C., is that certain populist messages touted by the likes of Warren, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, and Bernie Sanders will not be adopted by the incoming class of Democrats.
In fact, about 300 members of the incoming Congress are pro-crypto, according to Stand With Crypto. That’s three times the support we saw in 2022, and more than in our current Congress.
The midterm elections felt negative, but this is likely the most pro-crypto Congress we’ve ever had. And the industry might find itself in a better position now than ever.
And the similarities at the federal level don’t end there…
The U.S. Federal Reserve was raising interest rates in 2022. The target rate was around 4% at this time four years ago, on its way to 5.25% to 5.5% under the tutelage of Jerome Powell.
Today, the target rate is 3.75% to 4%, with expectations in December for another hike of 25 to 50 basis points.
Interest rate policy is hawkish.
Just like four years ago.
History is certainly rhyming, and here’s the strongest one…
The Lilly model depends on three variables.
One is the amount of liquidity in the financial system, tied to the U.S. Federal Reserve and U.S. Treasury.
The more dollars in the system, the more bullish for price.
The other variable is time. Bitcoin has shown an amazing tendency to rise over time. This rise is mathematical, which is why we can use a power law to assign possible price targets.
More specifically, we can create upper and lower bands within which price is expected to trade.
As for where price should sit within that band, that’s where the third variable comes in…
It’s tied to Bitcoin’s halving cycle. About 18 months before the next halving, Bitcoin tends to bottom out.
We can see the last time this happened was four years ago, in November 2022.
We are in that same setup today. It’s about 18 months before the next halving. And in our model, that’s when price is forecast to begin a multiyear bull run.
The setup is just as it was four years ago.
A similar capitulation event hit a major cryptocurrency exchange, the federal government shows similarities, and the timing relative to the halving looks similar.
This is the setup we’ve been waiting for.
Now it’s about waiting until we see price find support.
Once we see it, it’ll be time to build a two-year position.
This is what a four-year setup looks like. Don’t be put off by it. Be the one who sees what’s coming while others stay frozen in fear.
Your Pulse on Crypto,
Ben Lilly
Editor, Chain of Thought
Add Brownstone Research as your preferred source on Google to see our latest stories in your feed.
Read the latest insights from the world of high technology.
Musk didn’t engage in the pedantic discourse. He just built with his teams and made the impossible happen. He...
Two of the biggest names in tech history have suffered two starkly different events, causing very different kinds of...
In a compressed window of just a few weeks, three separate advanced reactor developers received meaningful regulatory clearances…